Skip to main content

MadaboutKitcars

This is a read-only archive of the old Madabout Kitcars forum. New posts and replies are no longer possible, but every thread is still here to browse and read.

Another Cordite Is Born ...

19 Feb 2015, 9:33pm
Mr T - Funnily enough, my build's rapidly approaching 3rd Birthday has actually been on my mind recently.

Part of the reason I have been messing about with my wiring is that I can't tackle the big jobs I need to do to get the body shell bonded on at the moment.

However, at some point I want to draw up a list of "must haves" to get on the road vs. "nice to haves" which I can come back to later.

The truth is I just can't face another winter trying to get this car on the road. :icon_sad:

But I'll write a proper post about this another day, cheers, Paul. :)
20 Feb 2015, 10:50am
In amongst the leg pulling and banter of the last few posts, there is a serious point about actually getting the car built.

This is something I have been thinking a lot about lately and, as I said, I will post some more thoughts about it another day.

The key thing for me it to keep sticking to KISS principles where ever possible.

Which ties in nicely with something I quickly managed to do this morning...

Bonnet Nose Colour:
Over on Scottie's XKSS build, Mick O'Malley posted a link to this D Type replica on Ebay.



Which is another variation on my own thoughts about painting a yellow band around my bonnet nose opening.



I was also considering painting the whole grille yellow for maximum impact and in honour of the Le Mans Spitfires. :cool:



But the KISS answer is to leave the grille in bare metal and fix it into position, rather than make it removable.

That would give me a BRG bonnet, signal yellow nose band and "metal" grille.

Whilst I still think a yellow, or even BRG, grille would look better, hopefully this combination should still look OK. :pray:

So I dug out this off cut from the sheet I cut the grille out of.



Not easy to see in this next photo, but I also roughly sanded the top surface of one small section.
( This is to represent the top surface if it gets scratched after fitting. )



I have now left this out in the open so see how it stands up to the rain.



I only wish I had thought about doing this earlier, as I could have left this section out over the whole winter. :rolleyes:

Cheers, Paul. :)
20 Feb 2015, 11:17am
Spray it occasionally with salty water; that will make-up for a missed winter.

Bury another piece under a light coating of soil and loosely cover it with something impermeable to retain the moisture.

You'll soon get an idea of how it will look after a short while on the car.
20 Feb 2015, 1:18pm
Paul if you want a shiney steel colour then you need stainless steel if its a rusty look then mild steel will go rusty in no time you could go for ally but this will need a coating for example anodized to prevent it looking naff.

Good luck with the experiment.
20 Feb 2015, 1:31pm
Ohhh, i'm looking forward to seeing how this turns out :)
20 Feb 2015, 4:42pm
Thanks for all the replies chaps. :cool:

Unfortunately, I am still on Half Term duty, so I need to be quick...

While I was thinking about the risk of rust on an untreated "metal" grille.

Previously I didn't think too hard about what kind of metal it actually was. :rolleyes:

So a bit of searching on Google and I have the following:

The grille is definitely not mild steel, as a magnet doesn't stick to it.

When I ran my grinder over this section, there were no sparks at all, which suggests it isn't stainless steel.



Therefore I think it is aluminium, as it is light and it was very easy to bend/break off a small section with just my fingers.

The piece I removed came off the area near the top of the grinder in the photo above so I could "plant" it in the veg. patch.



So if I have understood it right, it is oxidation I need to worry about, not rust.

Which leads me to Swifty's point about anodising which I have no experience of whatsoever. :icon_sad:

It seems there is both a hard & semi-hard process and the possibility of adding colour, in which case black would be great. :cool:

I will look into places that do this work round here, but if anyone can give me a ball park price it would be a big help.

The grille is 74 cm at the widest point and 37 cm at the deepest point.



Cheers, Paul. :)
20 Feb 2015, 5:46pm
Paul Can you easily cut the metal with hand snips and scratch quiet a deep line in to the surface with a scribe if so then it is ally plus the light weight is a give away, another point i can see in your photo's is the burred edge where it looks like you have used a cutting disc which happens to ally when cut with a disc plus the disc becomes clogged with the molten ally where as with stainless the disc cutting edge wears away quickly with no clogging.
Just thought i would give you my two peneth in case you have by chance bought stainless steel.

I am in the process of looking for a local company who does anodizing and so far they all charge a minimum price of £50 so it may be economical to have a few bits done for the min price.
21 Feb 2015, 7:12pm
Swifty - All advice gratefully received. :cool:
I've found a couple of anodising places not too far from here and I will bring the grille along to see what they think.
Depending on the price, I think that opting for a black grille could turn out to be a key element in the look of the car.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Reality Check:
Over the last few days I've been slowly putting together a post I was going to call "I hope I drive before I get old". :icon_wink:

As I am rapidly heading towards my build's 3rd birthday and, to be frank, there is absolutely no end date in sight. :icon_sad:

Part of me wants to justify the length of time it has taken me to get to the stage I am at the moment.

Another part of me would love to come up with a realistic finishing date taking into account all the outstanding jobs.
( I even had another flick through Mister Towed's build to remind myself of what lies ahead. )

However, despite typing up the major work completed & the scary amount of work still to do, I've decided not to post it after all. :rolleyes:

I can't deny that the thought of me still chipping away at this build through a 4th Winter is seriously depressing.

But if I try to force the pace of this build, I know I will be put myself under a level of stress that I really don't need.

The good news is that the more I thought about a dead line, the more I realised I should not care about setting one.

I did no work on the car today, as I was out with my family instead, including a visit inside the Tower of London.
( We wanted to do this after seeing the poppies there last year. )



This was just the reality check I needed, as whilst this car project means a lot to me, my family means more. :cool:

I guess the recent run of wet weather has got to me a bit, making me think my building prospects are worse than they are.

As the other reality is that I have actually made significant progress this Winter and can actually see my way to the finish line.

Which has to be a good thing, because there was a time when I really didn't think I would be able to fix all the problems I faced.

So whilst there is still a lot of work to do, I now know I am technically capable of doing each and every job required.

Even though it is hard to keep motivated at times, the simple fact is that I will get this car on the road eventually if I can just keep chipping away. :pray:

So I'll end on that more up beat note, take care, Paul. :)
21 Feb 2015, 8:39pm
Keep up the good work Paul.............
About the grill,seeing it i am afraid there is not enough airflow tru the grill for cooling.
Percentwise i'll guess there is only 35-40% of the surface cut away with the holes.
In the past i used to race 50cc motorbikes which i build myself,one time i build one with the radiator in front of the fairing using as a guard ally sheet drilled with 10mm holes very close together,later i was forced to use wire mesh to solve cooling problems.
Take a piece of left-over material,tape it at the end of a plastic 4inch pipe an tape some strips of light paper on it,then blow with a hairdryer into the pipe to see the airflow.
After doing this do the same with some wire mesh and spot the difference..........
.............or not.........your car............:humble:
René
21 Feb 2015, 11:01pm
Rene - Welcome to my build thread and feedback is always helpful. :cool:

I'm off to bed now, but I've just done a little bit of digging around for some photos.

The original bonnet grille from my donor Spitfire 1500 is at the bottom of this photo.



This vent was usually covered by the front number plate.
( Sorry I don't have a photo from my donor that I can use. )



So I really hope that the "holes" in this grille will provide at least a match, if not more air flow. :pray:



I will also be fitting a wider radiator than standard too.



I am certainly not an expert, so I'd rather know if I was making a mistake now.

Especially if I am going to spend some money to get the grille anodised.

Cheers, Paul. :)
21 Feb 2015, 11:04pm
Hi Paul, I've been so busy lately on my own build, I have not read up a lot on your's!

I agree with Reneanglia about the airflow, before I made that grill in my VW front panel, I did a lot of research on grilles and stuff, and it is surprising what one finds out.

Good companies selling different grille material will advertise the amount of gap/solid and give a percentage airflow figure. If they can't, they are not professional enough, and you could have overheating problems.

I personally would not use what you intend to, for those reasons. I would go for a good stainless woven mesh, and that way you will have no trouble with airflow or metal denegration. Check it out online.
21 Feb 2015, 11:09pm
Paul a bigger rad needs also cool air..........
If you take measurements of the stock grille open area and the open area of your grille i think you will be in for a surprise...........
Ofcourse i could be wrong but if i was you i want to be sure before spending money on it.


Oops,scottie beat me................must typ quicker
22 Feb 2015, 7:41am
Scottie & Rene - Thanks again for the feedback, as this is all new to me.
I've done a quick bit of research this morning, but still have a bit more to do.

Although my daughters have their friends coming round for an end of half term treat later today.
So my first priority is some domestic chores to prepare the house for that. :rolleyes:

But if I only get one "car" chore done today, it will be work out the number of the holes in the grille! :eek:
Then I can do some maths to work out the "open" area & draw that as a simple rectangle.
Then I can compare that rectangle to the area of the original Spitfire opening.

From what I have read this morning, it seems that people lower the number plate to improve air flow.



But that still looks like a small opening by comparison to the gaping hole in my bonnet.
Which is why I need to calculate how much of my grille is actually open.
As clearly my eyes are playing tricks on me if I don't take account of the solid part of the grille.

Building some "deflector boards" has always been on my "To Do" list, as my donor didn't have any.
( These are also recommended as a good way of keeping the engine cool. )



Other tips were switching from a mechanical fan to an electric one.
( Which is something many builders on here have done. )

Some people have also fitted oil coolers to their 1500 engines.

So clearly I need to do some more thinking, or simply admit defeat and change the grille.

Cheers, Paul. :)
22 Feb 2015, 8:10am
Paul, it isn't simply the cross sectional area of the holes.

Aerodynamics come into this, the large relative area of the plate will act as a dam, when the flow of the air ahead of the car hits what it sees as a plate with holes in it, the air will be compressed and spread sideways looking for the easiest way out, that will be sideways in this case. Some air will find it's way through the holes but not proportional to the cross sectional area of the holes because of the laminar and shear effect of the airflow. What you need is to do is either enlarge the holes until they are much greater than the area of the plate, taper and radius the edges of the holes to provide an easy 'slippery' entry, or revert to an alternative design. Think of the trumpets on Amal Carb...



You have to make it inviting for the air to pass through the grill, that usually means round wire or edge on slats (egg box grill?). Bulldozers do have grills similar to your design but they have massive fans to cool the engine and quite large holes, like inch?.
22 Feb 2015, 9:54am
I think you should put a beveled edge on each of the holes to attract the air... Or a couple of traffic cones, stuck on the front (may need adapting).
22 Feb 2015, 11:17am
Well Paul, at least now you are aware that a problem may exist, and that more re-search is required!

Now you know, and I'm sure you will sort it out ,traffic cones or not!!
22 Feb 2015, 11:55am
Perhaps i should'nt have mentioned the grill..........now your sunday is ruined..............
Good luck with the search of traffic cones...........
22 Feb 2015, 12:05pm
I'm just taking a short break after my morning's chores, so I'd better be quick...

KISS
Thanks for all the replies, links, explanations and suggestions chaps, as this is why I love this forum. :cool:

Having recently been monologuing about keeping this build simple, the least I can do is follow my own advice. :rolleyes:

So I hereby declare that I am abandoning the idea of using the "holey" grille altogether.

This isn't the first blind alley that my lack of knowledge has lead me down on this build.

But hopefully there will not be too many more. :pray:

I've just had a very quick look at the mesh grille that AndyP57 supplied.



This was to replace the "beer crate" grille that Sammio Gary never send, no doubt lost in the "Poole Triangle". :icon_wink:

Just for a short period of time I considered fitting this to get me through an MOT.

However, the simply reality is that I just don't like it.

So I have shamelessly stolen the grille idea that Mac had and just bought this.

Given that I would have needed to spend money to anodise the "holey" grille, this is only a marginal cost.

Then I can simply fit and forget it and more on to something else. :cool:

Cheers, Paul. :)

PS
My research did throw up some "interesting" photos.

The first seems to be following GaryH's traffic cone advice. :icon_twisted:



The second seems to be taking non standard pipe work to an extreme.



Well, that is until you find out the "engine" is a helicopter turbine! :eek:

22 Feb 2015, 1:00pm
""As I am rapidly heading towards my build's 3rd birthday and, to be frank, there is absolutely no end date in sight. "

Are you sure??.

Take a look at the progress you have made on the body...get that bonded on and I'll bet the build will move a heap quicker as you'll see the light at the end of the tunnel.
22 Feb 2015, 3:07pm
Paul, if you wanted a 'tea crate' grill, you can have mine.
22 Feb 2015, 5:36pm
Well my daughters and their friends are still having a good time, so all is well here. :cool:

Although I don't envy the poor pizza delivery guy who will shortly be heading our way in this weather. :eek:

But before he arrives I have a bit of time to write a couple of replies...

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

RedRatBike - Cheers, I really appreciate the vote of confidence. ::cool:

Ironically, writing down all the major modification work I'd done was starting to get me down.
As with so many things to fix, it has often felt like I have been trying to walk up the down escalator.
I have thrown a HUGE number of hours into this project just to get to where I should have started from.

But the good news is I have finally reached the point where the back of this build has been broken.
So once the weather starts to pick up I can strip it all back to the chassis for the final bits of prep. work.
Then I will really be able to say I am building the car and can finally bond the body shell into place. :pray:

Re-visiting Mister Towed's build was also a good boost to morale.
Clearly things like lining the internal cockpit walls can only be done when the body is bonded on.
However, once you sort out the cockpit sides, that's it, job done, no more mocking up, fitting, removing, re-fitting, etc.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Gary - Thanks for the offer. :cool:

Unfortunately, the thick mesh grille has now been paid for, so that will be my final design choice.
( Famous last words I know. :rolleyes: )

Also I get the impression that the Cordite has a bigger opening than the Spyder.
( As it looks like a Spyder bonnet hoop was cut in half to be factory fitted to my car. )

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Grille - Final Thoughts:
It has turned out to have been a bit of a roller coaster weekend since I posted a photo of a D type replica on Friday morning.

Even though some might view the change in direction for the grille as a step back for the build, I view it as a very positive thing.

I love the fact that people who know what they are talking about are prepared to step in to try and save me from myself. :cool:

I am also happy that the stubbornness that has kept me chipping away at this build doesn't extend to ignoring the facts.

I also glad I stuck to KISS and didn't work out a system of extra vents & ducts to compensate for fitting the wrong part. :rolleyes:

So despite the fact the some total of my weekend's work was a bit of shopping, this was still a good day.

Until next time, take care, Paul. :)
22 Feb 2015, 7:41pm
Good to see you have made a decision about the grill, its easier to rectify now, it's a nice looking grill you have decided to buy.

Paul at the rate you have been going since i arrived on the forum i suspect it will not be too long before you are finished so keep plugin away as the light at the end of tunnel is getting brighter by the day.
23 Feb 2015, 8:28am
Swifty - Thanks for your support & encouragement.

I think the recent long run of perpetually wet weather has just left me a bit stir crazy. :icon_sad:
Hopefully I will get a decent dry day soon, which will no doubt be just what I need to lift my spirits.

The other thing that is good for my morale is seeing the great work you and Mac are doing on your builds. :cool:
As there are so few Cordite / Navigator builds on the go, I have to steal my ideas for somewhere. :icon_wink:

Although at the moment I am desperately trying to keep alloy panels in the "nice to have" pile.
As the more panels you, Scottie & DaveCymru add to your builds, the more I like the look it gives.

But for now, I will try to focus on the enormous "need to have" pile of things to do. :rolleyes:

Cheers, Paul. :)
23 Feb 2015, 7:43pm
Hi Paul, you and I have both been over the weeks commenting on each others threads sympathising on our respective builds that have been thwarted by the weather. Again this weekend I found myself with car scheduled time but the rain or drizzle stopped play...

...I did find a way for octane fun though - cut back some shrubs, climbers and over hanging tree not wanting to stuff in my car to in my car I was left with one option. BURN so petrol can in one hand...



Good luck with the build, it looks to really be coming along well, when the sun shines